"In this unusual, challenging, interdisciplinary book, Collins and
Kusch have provided us with the best analysis we currently have of the
determinants of the possibilities of automation."
-- Donald MacKenzie, Department of Sociology,
University of Edinburgh
What can humans do? What can machines do? How do humans delegate
actions to machines? In this book, Harry Collins and Martin Kusch
combine insights from sociology and philosophy to provide a novel
answer to these increasingly important questions.
The authors begin by distinguishing between two basic types of
intentional behavior, which they call polimorphic actions and
mimeomorphicb actions. Polimorphic actions (such as writing a love
letter) are ones that community members expect to vary with social
context. Mimeomorphic actions (such a swinging a golf club) do not
vary. Although machines cannot act, they can mimic mimeomorphic
actions. Mimeomorphic actions are thus the crucial link between what
humans can do and what machines can do.
Following a presentation of their detailed categorization of actions,
the authors apply their approach to a broad range of human-machine
interactions and to learning. Key examples include bicycle riding and
the many varieties of writing machines. They also show how their
theory can be used to explain the operation of organizations such as
restaurants and armies. Finally, they look at a historical case --
the technological development of the air pump -- applying their
categorization of actions to the processes of mechanization and
automation. Automation, they argue, can occur only where what we want
to bring about can be brought about through mimeomorphic action.
|