"This book will be essential reading for philosophers who address questions concerning
the nature of folk objects, the basis for modal claims and our knowledge of such properties,
causation, vagueness, and much else."
-- William R. Carter, Professor of Philosophy, North Carolina State University
In Real Natures and Familiar Objects Crawford Elder defends, with qualifications,
the ontology of common sense. He argues that we exist-that no gloss is necessary
for the statement "human beings exist" to show that it is true of the world as it
really is-and that we are surrounded by many of the medium-sized objects in which
common sense believes. He argues further that these familiar medium-sized objects
not only exist, but have essential properties, which we are often able to determine
by observation. The starting point of his argument is that ontology should operate
under empirical load-that is, it should give special weight to the objects and properties
that we treat as real in our best predictions and explanations of what happens in the world.
Elder calls this presumption "mildly controversial" because it entails that arguments are
needed for certain widely assumed positions such as "mereological universalism"
(according to which the sum of randomly assembled objects constitutes an object in
its own right).
|