|
Freud's Dream provides an extended case study of the
appeal and potential dangers of the interdisciplinary approach to
theory construction now guiding cognitive science as well as a novel
interpretation of Freud's own program.
Kitcher argues that Freud's grand scheme for psychoanalysis was
nothing less than a blueprint for a complete interdisciplinary science
of mind, that many of its strengths and weaknesses derived from that
fact, and that Freud's errors are instructive for current work in
cognitive science.
In particular, Kitcher maintains that Freud's metapsychology was not a
dispensible theoretical superstructure but a set of directives for
constructing a science of mind that would be firmly grounded in then
current results in neurophysiology, evolutionary biology, psychology,
psychiatry, and the social sciences. The collapse of psychoanalysis,
Kitcher asserts, was due in large measure to fundamental changes in
the sciences out of which Freud constructed his theories and his
refusal to recognize the degree to which he had made psychoanalysis
dependent on the results and assumptions of nineteenth-century
science.
Patricia Kitcher is Professor of Philosophy at the University of
California, San Diego, and President of the Society for Philosophy and
Psychology.
|