"This book is certainly going to count as one of the most important
contributions to the philosophy of mathematics of the last
decades."
-- Paolo Mancosu, Assistant Professor of Philosphy,
University of California, Berkeley
In Realistic Rationalism, Jerrold J. Katz develops a new
philosophical position integrating realism and rationalism. Realism
here means that the objects of study in mathematics and other formal
sciences are abstract; rationalism means that our knowledge of them is
not empirical. Katz uses this position to meet the principal
challenges to realism. In exposing the flaws in criticisms of the
antirealists, he shows that realists can explain knowledge of abstract
objects without supposing we have causal contact with them, that
numbers are determinate objects, and that the standard counterexamples
to the abstract/concrete distinction have no force. Generalizing the
account of knowledge used to meet the challenges to realism, he
develops a rationalist and non-naturalist account of philosophical
knowledge and argues that it is preferable to contemporary naturalist
and empiricist accounts. The book illuminates a wide range of
philosophical issues, including the nature of necessity, the
distinction between the formal and natural sciences, empiricist
holism, the structure of ontology, and philosophical
skepticism. Philosophers will use this fresh treatment of realism and
rationalism as a starting point for new directions in their own
research.
|