"...it is a truly admirable work, and should prove extremely valuable.
There is really nothing to compete with it for its broad scope and
lively, easy style."
-- John Ziman, Professor Emeritus of Physics at the
University of Bristol, and Fellow of the Royal Society.
"The fish's streamlined shape reveals functional knowledge of the
physical properties of water.... The deadly effectiveness of the
cobra's venom shows useful knowledge of the physiology of its prey....
Indeed, knowledge itself may be broadly conceived as the fit of some
aspect of an organism to some aspect of its environment, whether it be
the fit of the butterfly's long siphon of a mouth to the flowers from
which it feeds or the fit of the astrophysicist's theories to the
structure of the universe. ... But how did such remarkable instances
of fit arise? How did the animate world obtain its impressive
knowledge of its surroundings? And how do organisms continue to
acquire knowledge and thereby increase their fit during their
lifetimes?"
In this sweeping account of the emergence of fit, Gary Cziko
integrates numerous scientific disciplines within the perspective of a
universal selection theory that attempts to account for all cases of
fit involving living organisms, including those that might appear
miraculous. Cziko's bold assertion is that all novel forms of adapted
complexity -- whether single-celled organisms or scientific theories
-- emerge from an evolutionary process involving cumulative blind
variation and selection.
Without Miracles describes many remarkable examples of
the fit of various structures, behaviors, and products of living
organisms to their environments in a broad synthesis of humankind's
attempt to understand the emergence of complex, adapted entities.
These explanations range from the providential accounts of the early
philosophers and "natural theologians," through instructionist
theories of the type proposed by Lamarck, to an ongoing "second
Darwinian revolution" in which natural and artificial selection are
being applied to many fields of science to both explain the emergence
of naturally occurring adapted complexity and to facilitate the design
of useful products ranging from microbes to computer programs.
The evolution of explanations of fit from providential through
instructionist to selectionist theories, Cziko argues, has occurred
repeatedly in many different fields of knowledge along with a growing
realization that the Darwinian mechanism of cumulative blind variation
and selection is the only tenable nonmiraculous explanation for the
emergence of any kind of functional complexity.
Cziko applies this provocative selectionist thesis to a stunning range
of domains including biology, immunology, neuroscience, ethology,
psychology, anthropology, philosophy, education, linguistics, and
computer science. The result is an up-to-date, clearly summarized
collection of selectionist arguments that shows how our knowledge of
the emergence of fit has itself evolved and continues to do so.
|