MIT CogNet, The Brain Sciences ConnectionFrom the MIT Press, Link to Online Catalog
SPARC Communities
Subscriber : Stanford University Libraries » LOG IN

space

Powered By Google 
Advanced Search

 

ERP Evidence for the Priority of Phrase Structure Information Over Argument Structure Information in Sentence Processing

 Stefan Frisch, Anja Hahne and Angela D. Friederici
  
 

Abstract:
Abstract: There is an ongoing debate in psycholinguistic research about whether phrase structure information is processed prior to or interactively with argument structure (e.g., transitivity) information of verbs during the earliest steps of structure building (cf. Mitchell 1994). We addressed this issue by using sentences with two different types of violations on the identical item in the sentence (cf. Friederici, Steinhauer & Frisch 1999). Sentences were either (a) correct, or realized (b) a phrase-structure violation, (c) an argument structure violation or (d) both types of violation simultanously. In two ERP studies (visual versus auditory sentence presentation), we found a biphasic N400-P600 pattern when there was an argument structure violation but no additional phrase structure violation, that is, only in condition (c). The patterns in the double violation condition (d) and in condition (b) with a phrase structure violation only did not differ from each other in either modality. Results show that phrase structure information is processed prior to argument structure information and therefore support phrase structure driven models of parsing (cf. Frazier 1987).

 
 


© 2010 The MIT Press
MIT Logo